Current:Home > MyCan animals really predict earthquakes? Evidence is shaky, scientists say -Ascend Finance Compass
Can animals really predict earthquakes? Evidence is shaky, scientists say
View
Date:2025-04-22 23:03:05
Editor's note: A version of this story originally ran in 2018
Should you worry about an earthquake if you see Fluffy or Fido acting strangely?
For thousands of years, people have claimed that odd behavior by cats, dogs, snakes, bugs and even cows could predict an imminent earthquake, but a 2018 study — apparently the first rigorous analysis of the phenomenon — found there is no strong evidence behind the claim.
There were some reports of odd animal behavior around the 4.8 magnitude quake that struck the New York-New Jersey area on Friday, but such reports are often anecdotal and unsuitable for sound investigation, the study said, since they don't follow even the most basic scientific methodology.
"The reports of conspicuous behavior are numerous, but it could have other causes," said study lead author a Heiko Woith, a hydrogeologist at the German Research Centre for Geosciences in Potsdam. "Many review papers on the potential of animals as earthquake precursors exist, but to the best of our knowledge, this is the first time that a statistical approach was used to evaluate the data."
Animal behavior in 160 earthquakes reviewed
The researchers studied 729 reports of abnormal animal behavior related to 160 earthquakes and reviewed unusual behavior from more than 130 species, from sheep to goats to snakes and fish. Though the reports come from two dozen countries, most were from New Zealand, Japan, Italy and Taiwan.
According to the U.S. Geological Survey (USGS), the earliest reference to unusual animal behavior prior to a significant earthquake is from Greece in 373 BC. "Rats, weasels, snakes, and centipedes reportedly left their homes and headed for safety several days before a destructive earthquake," the USGS said.
The USGS said while it's possible for animals to pick up on subtle ground movements a few seconds before the main quake, but that's about it.
"As for sensing an impending earthquake days or weeks before it occurs, that's a different story," the USGS said.
The 'lost pet' correlation in the Bay Area
A once popular urban legend purported a correlation between "Lost Pet" ads in the San Jose Mercury News and the dates of earthquakes in the San Francisco Bay area. A statistical analysis of that theory, published in California Geology in 1988, concluded that there was no such correlation, however.
The majority of the reports in the 2018 study came from three events: the 2010 Darfield earthquake in New Zealand, the 1984 Nagano-ken Seibu earthquake in Japan and the 2009 L’Aquila earthquake in Italy.
The unusual animal behavior occurred anywhere from seconds to months prior to the earthquakes, and at distances from a few to hundreds of miles from the earthquake epicenter. Only 14 of the reports record a series of observations of the animals over time — most reports are single observations.
These weaknesses in the data make it difficult to confirm these behaviors are actual predictions, meaning they signal an earthquake event before the event begins, rather than random occurrences or behaviors linked to the initial stages of an earthquake, such as foreshocks.
According to Woith: "an accurate prediction of the location, magnitude and time of a quake seems, according to everything we know, to be impossible. And a reliable early warning on the basis of foreshocks or release of gases from the ground has many uncertainties and has, so far, not succeeded even with the most modern sensors."
The study was published in the Bulletin of the Seismological Society of America.
veryGood! (2)
Related
- South Korean president's party divided over defiant martial law speech
- 14 workers hospitalized for carbon monoxide poisoning at Yale building under construction
- Haitian university officials face investigation over allegations of sexual abuse
- Champion Bodybuilder Chad McCrary Dead at 49
- A South Texas lawmaker’s 15
- Prince William Visits Kate Middleton in Hospital Amid Her Recovery From Surgery
- Southern Charm's Olivia Flowers Shares Heartbreaking Update One Year After Brother Conner's Death
- Ariana Madix Shares the Sweetest Update on Boyfriend Daniel Wai Ahead of Broadway Debut
- Average rate on 30
- Senegal presidential candidate renounces French nationality to run for office
Ranking
- A South Texas lawmaker’s 15
- Sophie Turner, Joe Jonas resolve lawsuit as they determine shared custody of daughters
- Bid by meatpacker JBS to join New York Stock Exchange faces opposition over Amazon deforestation
- 14 workers hospitalized for carbon monoxide poisoning at Yale building under construction
- DeepSeek: Did a little known Chinese startup cause a 'Sputnik moment' for AI?
- Haitian university officials face investigation over allegations of sexual abuse
- 9/11 victim’s remains identified nearly 23 years later as Long Island man
- Woman alleges long-term heart problems caused by Panera Bread's caffeinated lemonade
Recommendation
'Most Whopper
Two officers shot, man killed by police in gunfire exchange at Miami home, officials say
Grading Pascal Siakam trade to Pacers. How Raptors, Pelicans also made out
Warriors vs. Mavericks game postponed following death of assistant coach Dejan Milojević
The White House is cracking down on overdraft fees
What to know about the Justice Department’s report on police failures in the Uvalde school shooting
Stock market today: Asian shares trade mixed after Wall Street dips amid dimming rate cut hopes
‘Stop Cop City’ attacks have caused costs to rise for Atlanta police training center, officials say