Current:Home > ContactFormer Wisconsin Supreme Court justice fights order to appear in court over impeachment advice -Ascend Finance Compass
Former Wisconsin Supreme Court justice fights order to appear in court over impeachment advice
View
Date:2025-04-14 13:21:05
MADISON, Wis. (AP) — A former Wisconsin Supreme Court justice is fighting a subpoena ordering her to appear in court in a lawsuit related to advice she gave about possible impeachment of a current liberal justice, calling it “unreasonable and oppressive.”
Republican lawmakers have threatened possible impeachment of current Justice Janet Protasiewicz related to comments she made during the campaign calling GOP-drawn legislative maps “rigged” and “unfair.” She joined with the liberal majority of the court in agreeing to hear a lawsuit supported by Democrats that seeks to overturn the GOP maps and enact new ones.
Wisconsin Republican Assembly Speaker Robin Vos asked three former conservative Supreme Court justices for advice on impeachment. Two of the three told him that impeaching Protasiewicz was not warranted. The third, former Chief Justice Patience Roggensack, has not said what her advice was and Vos has repeatedly refused to disclose it.
The liberal watchdog group American Oversight filed a lawsuit alleging that the three former justices researching impeachment for Vos had violated both the state open meetings and open records laws. American Oversight wants the judge to order the former justices to meet in public and to release records related to their work. It was also seeking attorneys fees.
Last week, Roggensack received a subpoena compelling her to attend a hearing in the case was scheduled for this Thursday. On Monday, she asked to be released from the subpoena.
“I believe it would be unreasonable and oppressive to require me to appear at a hearing on a motion for preliminary injunction and even for the Court to consider such a motion,” Roggensack wrote.
The judge scheduled another hearing for Wednesday afternoon, likely to address Roggensack’s request.
Roggensack, in her affidavit with the court, said the order being sought, which included requiring the former justices to meet in public, would impair her First Amendment rights of freedom of expression, peaceably assembling and petitioning the government.
Roggensack said that Vos, the Republican legislator, asked for her advice on impeachment. Roggensack said she told him she had been researching the issue on her own “because I found the topic to be interesting and because I had not previously considered the standards for impeachment of a Supreme Court justice.”
Roggensack said she never considered Vos’s request to mean she was becoming part of a governmental body or committee as American Oversight alleged in its lawsuit.
Vos himself called the effort a panel when he announced in September that he was seeking their advice.
Roggensack said she had a lunch with the other two former justices, David Prosser and Jon Wilcox, along with Vos’s attorney. Prosser and Wilcox have also said that was the only meeting the three former justices had. They all said that they separately advised Vos and did not collaborate on their advice.
American Oversight filed open records requests with the former justices. Prosser released the email he sent Vos that included his impeachment advice, as well as voicemail messages from Roggensack and text messages they exchanged.
Neither Wilcox, Roggensack, nor Vos’ office have responded to its requests for records, American Oversight said.
Vos originally said he was considering impeachment if Protasiewicz did not recuse herself from the redistricting case. She didn’t recuse. Vos didn’t move to impeach her, following the advice against impeachment from the former justices. But now he’s suggesting he may attempt to impeach her if she does not rule in favor of upholding the current Republican maps.
The Wisconsin Constitution reserves impeachment for “corrupt conduct in office, or for crimes and misdemeanors.”
veryGood! (6)
Related
- Warm inflation data keep S&P 500, Dow, Nasdaq under wraps before Fed meeting next week
- A New York village known for its majestic mute swans faces a difficult choice after one is killed
- Sum 41's Deryck Whibley alleges sex abuse by ex-manager: Biggest revelations from memoir
- Bacon hogs the spotlight in election debates, but reasons for its sizzling inflation are complex
- Buckingham Palace staff under investigation for 'bar brawl'
- McDonald's Chicken Big Mac debuts this week: Here's what's on it and when you can get one
- Jennifer Lopez says divorce from Ben Affleck was 'probably the hardest time of my life'
- Anne Hathaway Apologizes to Reporter for Awkward 2012 Interview
- $73.5M beach replenishment project starts in January at Jersey Shore
- Netflix's 'Heartstopper' tackled teen sex. It sparked an important conversation.
Ranking
- The Louvre will be renovated and the 'Mona Lisa' will have her own room
- Opinion: Duke's Jon Scheyer faces unique pressure with top prospect Cooper Flagg on team
- Uber, Lyft drivers fight for higher pay, better protections
- Dodgers vs. Padres live score updates: San Diego can end NLDS, Game 4 time, channel
- New Mexico governor seeks funding to recycle fracking water, expand preschool, treat mental health
- Phaedra Parks Slams “Ding-a-Ling” Gene Simmons Over Dancing With the Stars Low Score
- Pharrell, Lewis Hamilton and A$AP Rocky headline Met Gala 2025 co-chairs
- Stanley Tucci Shares The One Dish Wife Felicity Blunt Won’t Let Him Cook for Christmas
Recommendation
Trump invites nearly all federal workers to quit now, get paid through September
Prince William Shares Royally Relatable Parenting Confession About His and Kate Middleton's Kids
Taylor Swift Donates $5 Million to Hurricane Milton and Hurricane Helene Victims
16-year-old bicyclist struck, driven 4 miles while trapped on car's roof: Police
Paris Hilton, Nicole Richie return for an 'Encore,' reminisce about 'The Simple Life'
'Survivor' Season 47: Idols, advantages, arguments, oh my! Who went home on Episode 4?
When will Malik Nabers return? Latest injury updates on Giants WR
'Golden Bachelorette' judges male strip contest. Who got a rose and who left in Ep. 4?