Current:Home > MarketsGoodreads has a 'review bombing' problem — and wants its users to help solve it -Ascend Finance Compass
Goodreads has a 'review bombing' problem — and wants its users to help solve it
View
Date:2025-04-15 08:59:49
Cait Corrain was about to achieve the dream of every aspiring writer by publishing her first novel. Instead, her career has imploded following a controversy involving Goodreads, the popular book-lovers' website.
On Tuesday, Corrain's publisher, Del Rey Books, an imprint of Penguin Random House, said it would cancel publication of Corrain's novel, a science fiction fantasy called Crown of Starlight, after she admitted writing fake Goodreads reviews lauding her own book and excoriating works by other novelists. Corrain's literary agent has also cut ties with her.
This is not the first time Goodreads, which allows its 90 million users to rate books using one to five stars, has been the subject of a controversy involving its reviews. Earlier this year, the best-selling author Elizabeth Gilbert withdrew an upcoming novel about a Soviet-era family because critics wrongly assumed it was pro-Russian and flooded the site with one-star reviews.
Amazon-owned Goodreads makes little effort to verify users, and critics say this enables a practice known as review-bombing, in which a book is flooded with negative reviews, often from fake accounts, in an effort to bring down a its rating, sometimes for reasons having nothing to do with the book's contents.
Review-bombing can devastate a book's prospects, especially when the writer is little known or publishing for the first time.
"When a reader who is considering buying your book sees that you are controversial or your book is controversial, that's going to make them shy away from it," says writer and editor Lindsay Ellis. She says she herself was review-bombed because she had criticized author J. K. Rowling's remarks about the transgender community.
Corrain's downfall came after internet sleuths published a Google document detailing a number of Goodreads accounts praising Crown of Starlight and giving low reviews to works by other writers, many of them people of color.
Corrain first claimed that the reviews had been created by an overly zealous friend named Lilly who was attempting to boost the book's prospects. She later conceded she herself was the author, writing a lengthy apology in which she attributed her actions to "a complete psychological breakdown."
The author subsequently shut down her social media accounts and could not be reached for comment.
Goodreads said it has removed the fake reviews posted by Corrain, and in a statement issued last month it urged users to flag other suspicious accounts.
It also said it would increase efforts "to quickly detect and moderate content and accounts that violate our reviews or community guidelines," by intervening during periods of intense activity that suggest efforts to review-bomb a book.
Publishing industry veteran Jane Friedman says the move would stop efforts to review-bomb popular writers such as Gilbert. But she said it would probably do little to protect most other writers.
"That's very welcome and I hope they do continue that, but this low-level review bombing, it's never going to catch that sort of activity because it's too small," she said.
Goodreads relies on a team of volunteer "librarians" to ensure the accuracy of information about books and authors, but the sheer number of reviews the site publishes — more than 300 million ratings in the past year alone — makes it subject to abuses.
"Goodreads just makes it so easy to engage in that bad behavior," Friedman says.
One unusual feature about Goodreads is that it allows reviews to be posted before a book has been published, which helps generate early buzz. Many publishers even send out early copies to influential Goodreads users, hoping they will talk up the book.
Sometimes, reviews are published even before a book is finished.
George R. R. Martin's seventh book in his phenomenally popular "A Song of Ice and Fire" series has already generated thousands of reviews. He hasn't yet finished the sixth.
veryGood! (51)
Related
- A Mississippi company is sentenced for mislabeling cheap seafood as premium local fish
- Suspect arrested after allegedly killing a man at a northern New Mexico rest stop, stealing cars
- Parts of central US hit by severe storms, while tornadoes strike in Kansas and Iowa
- Supreme Court appears divided over obstruction law used to prosecute Trump, Jan. 6 rioters
- Friday the 13th luck? 13 past Mega Millions jackpot wins in December. See top 10 lottery prizes
- How Kansas women’s disappearance on a drive to pick up kids led to 4 arrests in Oklahoma
- Genesis guitarist Steve Hackett rushed to hospital moments before his concert
- Ben & Jerry's Free Cone Day is back: How to get free ice cream at shops Tuesday
- The Grammy nominee you need to hear: Esperanza Spalding
- Barbie craze extends to summer grilling with Heinz Classic Barbiecue Sauce
Ranking
- Friday the 13th luck? 13 past Mega Millions jackpot wins in December. See top 10 lottery prizes
- Ukraine prime minister calls for more investment in war-torn country during Chicago stop of US visit
- Lottery, gambling bill heads to Alabama legislative conference committee for negotiations
- Arkansas lawmakers question governor’s staff about purchase of $19,000 lectern cited by audit
- $73.5M beach replenishment project starts in January at Jersey Shore
- Texas inmate Melissa Lucio’s death sentence should be overturned, judge says
- Michigan attorney general to announce charges in investigation of former top lawmaker
- Shannen Doherty Shares Lessons Learned From Brutal Marriage to Ex Kurt Iswarienko
Recommendation
Will the 'Yellowstone' finale be the last episode? What we know about Season 6, spinoffs
Federal appeals court overturns West Virginia transgender sports ban
I just paid my taxes. Biden's pandering on student loans will end up costing us all more.
Supreme Court allows Idaho to enforce ban on gender-affirming care for nearly all transgender minors for now
Warm inflation data keep S&P 500, Dow, Nasdaq under wraps before Fed meeting next week
The 10 Best Linen Pants To Rock This Summer
Utility regulators approve plan for Georgia Power to add new generating capacity
Connecticut’s top public defender denies misconduct claims as commission debates firing her